Obama switches sides on China 

American policy toward China is defined by a debate between the ‘functionalists’ and the ‘strategists.’ This time last year, ‘strategists’ were being sidelined as impractical trouble-makers and the functionalists were ascendant. But China’s increased assertiveness over the past few months has changed the Obama administration’s approach. In the competitive and sometimes nasty world of international politics, strategists now hold sway and functionalists are increasingly on the defensive.

First things first: what do these two sides believe? Strongly supported by many Democrats, the functionalists are mostly economists, or those who focus on the benefits of the economic relationship. Usually urbane and warning against the demonization of China, they argue that the United States and China are so economically intertwined that both sides have an overwhelming interest in avoiding war. Functionalists openly admit that serious disagreements exist. But they argue that the best way to proceed is to treat China as a strategic partner since this will promote win-win cooperation rather than zero-sum competition. Since tensions are due largely to misunderstanding rather than fundamental disagreement, closer economic and strategic integration will dissolve the most serious bilateral problems. 

On the other hand, strategists  acknowledge the complex reality of the economic relationship but nevertheless believe that there is an irreversible rivalry between the two countries. Strategists seek tactical cooperation where available but view strategic competition with China as inevitable and already occurring.

The latter part of 2009 profoundly demonstrated the failure of Washington’s functionalist approach: President Barack Obama’s humiliating visit to Beijing in November followed by Chinese intransigence at the Copenhagen Climate Change conference the following month.

The first six months of 2010 has not been much better. As the United States struggled with the consequences of the global financial crisis, a normally cautious China has become more confident and antagonistic. There was the U.S. siding with Google when it threatened to pull out of China over censorship concerns, and the routine dispute over U.S. arms sales to Taiwan.

But it seems that the final straw for Obama was increased Chinese assertiveness over the majority of the South China Sea which Beijing sees as its “territorial waters.” Beijing has long made the same declaration but has only recently characterized reclaiming the South China Sea as amongst its “core interests” — seemingly equating the busy and resource-rich waters with other “core interests” such as reclaiming Taiwan and preventing independence movements in Tibet and Xinjiang.

Since the Copenhagen summit, there has been a steady stream of whispers in Washington that Obama will finally abandon the functionalists and join the strategists. Recent signs suggest this is finally happening. At the ASEAN meeting in Hanoi last week, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton upped the ante by offering to work with all parties and declared a peaceful resolution to the South China Sea issue as in America’s “national interest.”

This is significant for two reasons. First, this explicitly signals American preparedness to lend its considerable if not decisive weight to resolving disputes over an issue China treats as its ‘core interest.’ Second, it signals a renewed American preparedness to join with regional allies and partners in checking China’s ambition. It is no coincidence that last week also witnessed another step toward restoring full military ties between America and Indonesia when Secretary of Defense Robert Gates announced that Pentagon will resume training with Koppassus, Indonesia’s Special Forces unit.

These are still early days for “Obama the strategist.” He has yet to make any statement about Washington’s grand strategy to manage China’s rise. Be that as it may, the functionalists are cowed for the moment.

John Lee is a foreign policy research fellow at The Centre for Independent Studies and a Visiting Fellow at the Hudson Institute in Washington, D.C. This article appeared in The Weekly Standard.

About The Author

Staff Report

Staff Report

A daily newspaper covering San Francisco, San Mateo County and serving Alameda, Marin and Santa Clara counties.
Pin It

Speaking of...

More by Staff Report

Latest in Nation

© 2019 The San Francisco Examiner

Website powered by Foundation