Did Hillary Clinton help bring down Tunisia's Ben Ali? 

Tunisia’s president Zine El Abidine Ben Ali abandoned his post on Friday after 23 years, and has reportedly landed in Saudi Arabia. To retire from the position of president-for-life is an exceedingly rare move for an Arab regime chief. Indeed, no modern Arab ruler before Ben Ali has ever willingly stepped aside. Most transfers of power in the region are either through inheritance or coup, bloodless or otherwise.

Ben Ali’s accession to the presidency was a relatively peaceful affair, when he replaced Habib Borguiba whom Ben Ali, then the prime minister, deemed no longer capable of ruling. Borguiba is regarded as the father of modern, and secular, Tunisia—he’s the Tunisian Ataturk. The paradox is that the reforms that led to Tunis’s pro-Western orientation were earned through oppressive and extreme—i.e., non-democratic, non-Western—measures at the hands of the country’s security services. If in the past these intelligence agencies had done the lion’s share of their work behind closed doors (most likely torturing the Islamist opposition since the fundamentalists are always those most likely to oppose Westernizing reforms and challenge any Muslim regime’s political legitimacy), they’ve spent the last few weeks in the open daylight cracking open the skulls of protestors in the streets. Pictures and videos taken from the emergency rooms holding wounded and murdered demonstrators have been circulating the last few days, which likely helped turn the international consensus against the Tunis government and hastened Ben Ali’s downward spiral. The question is, did Washington play any role in toppling an Arab strongman?

Over the last two years the Obama administration has rightly been excoriated for ignoring human rights issues throughout the Arabic-speaking Middle East. The White House gave a free pass to allies, like Egypt and Saudi Arabia, that the Bush team had pressed for reforms. The adversaries that the previous administration sought to isolate like Syria, which locked up its own dissidents while murdering Lebanese activists, Obama wanted to engage. But Thursday afternoon in Doha Secretary Clinton fired a shot across the bow of the Arab political order.

In the Middle East, Clinton said:

one in five young people is unemployed. And in some places, the percentage is far more. While some countries have made great strides in governance, in many others people have grown tired of corrupt institutions and a stagnant political order. They are demanding reform to make their governments more effective, more responsive, and more open. And all this is taking place against a backdrop of depleting resources: water tables are dropping, oil reserves are running out, and too few countries have adopted long-term plans for addressing these problems.

In taking the side of Arab individuals against their ruling regimes, Clinton was reminiscent of the most optimistic days of the Bush administration’s freedom agenda, circa 2005. It is worth wondering what Clinton’s words might have indicated to both the regime and its opponents.

Read more at the Weekly Standard

About The Author

Lee Smith

Pin It
Favorite

Speaking of...

Latest in Nation

© 2018 The San Francisco Examiner

Website powered by Foundation