Court turns down Drakes Bay Oyster Co. bid for rehearing 

click to enlarge Drake's Bay Oyster Co.
  • Eric Risberg/2012 AP file photo
  • Drake's Bay Oyster Co. lost the latest round in its fight to stay open after the 9th U.S. Circuit Court rejected its bid to have its case heard by an 11-judge panel.

An oyster farm in the Point Reyes National Seashore today lost another round in its fight to stay open.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court Appeals in San Francisco turned down a bid by the Drakes Bay Oyster Co. to have its case reconsidered by an expanded 11-judge panel.

The oyster farm is challenging a decision by former Interior Secretary Kenneth Salazar in 2012 to refuse a lease extension. The decision, if upheld, would force the oyster farm to close and allow the site to return to wilderness.

The company had asked the appeals court to have an expanded panel review a ruling in which a three-judge panel of the circuit court in September refused by a 2-1 vote to block Salazar's decision from going into effect.

The court said in an order today that the farm's request for a rehearing by an 11-judge panel had been forwarded to the full 27-member appeals court, and no judge on the court had called for a vote on whether to grant a rehearing.

The farm has one more possible step in its appeal -- a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Peter Prows, a lawyer for the oyster company, said, "We are contemplating our next steps."

Oyster farm spokeswoman Tina Walker said, "We strongly disagree" with the denial of a rehearing.

The farm has been allowed to continue operating during its appeals.

The private company grows oysters on 1,000 acres of submerged land in Drakes Estero, an estuary of Drakes Bay, and packages them on 1.5 acres of land along the shoreline. It says it produces more than a third of all oysters grown in California.

Owners Kevin and Nancy Lunny bought the operation from a predecessor company in 2004 and took over a 40-year permit that expired in 2012.

The company sued the Interior Department in 2012 to challenge Salazar's decision. It appealed to the 9th Circuit after U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzales Rogers of Oakland declined to grant a preliminary injunction blocking the closure. The trial judge said Salazar had "complete discretion" to decide whether to renew the permit.

Neal Desai, a spokesman for the National Parks Conservation Association, said, "This is a strong ruling that affirms our national parks will be preserved.

"We've waited for 40 years and now it's time to return this gem to the wilderness for all Americans," Desai said.

About The Author

Bay City News

Pin It

More by Bay City News

Latest in California

© 2019 The San Francisco Examiner

Website powered by Foundation