Allegedly "devestating" Daniels video actually makes him look pretty good 

The Washington Post's Jennifer Rubin is no fan of Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels, and last night she posted a two-year old video clip of him that she claimed was "devestating."

What was so awful about it?

At one point in the June 2009 speech to the Ripon Society, Daniels said,  "The whole concept of a wedge issue should be foreign to us if we really want to come back.”

Because of this, Rubin wrote a post headlined, "Mitch Daniels: No issues the Democrats don't like."

Rubin opines, "That is not what the party’s base wants to hear. They want to set the agenda, not capitulate before beginning the bargaining. More than any single issue, it is this attitude that will be an anathema to the Republican primary electorate."

It's one thing if his argument were of the Charlie Crist variety -- that somehow Republicans had to abandon their principles to get back on top. But that's clearly not the point Daniels was making here if you watch his entire remarks.

All he was saying in the part of the speech Rubin highlighted is that Republicans should try to appeal to average Americans by being more likable and emphasizing issues that unite more people. In the rest of the speech, he rejected the idea that Americans were ready to embrace statism and noted that the public's suspicion of government and fear of deficits was at an all time high and that the Republican message could succeed in that environment.

“There is absolutely nothing flawed about the principles that either Ripon or Republicanism generally has always stood for," Daniels said. "And I've been thinking about this a lot lately, because it's an open question. People are writing about it all the time. 'Have Americans embraced the new statism, (do they) have a new receptiveness to statism?' I don't think so.”

He continued:  “American suspicion of bigness, whether it's government, business or labor, I don't think has diminished. If we are a party of individual rights, small business, competition, I think we'll still get a receptive ear.”

Daniels went on to speak about the debt and Obama's spending binge.

“The American people's skepticism about debt and deficits I think is at an all time high, not only because of what they're seeing in the public sector – most states, the federal government – but think about their lives," he said. "Americans just came through a period where either they or their neighbors, or a business they were involved in, saved too little, borrowed too much, spent too much, didn't work out too well. That door is about to be thrown wide open by the policies of this administration.”

He was even optimistic about the ability of Republicans to win over the youth vote.

“I just do not see in Americans today, the young people in particular, an embrace of collectivism, of statism," Daniels said. "Quite the contrary. Almost to a fault, they insist on individual choice and almost limitless freedom. And I don't think they're going to be naturally herded together by government however charismatically it is presented. Into unions, or mass transit, or in any other fashion that infringes on what they see as their God-given right to make their own choices."

Keep in mind that at the time he was making these remarks, there was plenty of reason for GOP pessimism -- Obama's approval rating was still at a resilient 60 percent it was several months before Chris Christie and Bob McDonnell had won their governorships.

Far from being "devastating," the video actually makes Daniels come across as a mainstream (and prescient) conservative who predicted that the Republican Party could win by emphasizing solutions to real world problems and limited government principles.

Should he run, Daniels will have a number of things to answer for with the base. But this video won't be one of them.

Watch part one of the speech here. Part two, which Rubin seized on, is embedded below.


About The Author

Philip Klein

Pin It

More by Philip Klein

Latest in Nation

© 2019 The San Francisco Examiner

Website powered by Foundation